Portfolio Rebalancing in a Bear Market: What to Do Right Now
With the S&P 500 down nearly 5% in a week and the VIX at 28, your target allocation is probably a distant memory

Ticker Ratings
Remember when you set up that tidy 60/40 portfolio five years ago and felt like a responsible adult? Morningstar's Christine Benz has bad news: that same portfolio is now sitting at roughly 75% US equities. You didn't do anything wrong. The market just kept going up, and now you're carrying way more risk than you intended, right at the moment the market decided to remind everyone that gravity is real.
The S&P 500 has shed 5.3% in a single week, sliding from 7,561 to 7,175. The VIX has spiked to 28.44, up nearly 47% across the past week alone, which is Wall Street's way of screaming into a pillow. Iran attacking US bases in the Gulf, tanker incidents near the Strait of Hormuz, a potential government shutdown, and a three-way Trump-Xi-Putin summit that produced a peace declaration nobody fully trusts: this is not a calm market. This is a market that skipped its therapy appointment.
So what do you actually do? The Investor's Business Daily crowd is sitting mostly in cash and watching for a follow-through day, defined as a strong power day on day four or later of a rally attempt, before re-entering. That's one approach. The rebalancing approach is different: it's not about timing the bottom, it's about mechanically trimming what's grown too large and adding to what's shrunk. If your equities have dropped 5% this week but bonds have caught a bid (the 10-year Treasury yield fell to 5.04% as investors fled to safety), your allocation may have already self-corrected a little. The key is knowing your target before you start pulling triggers.
The tax angle matters enormously here. Benz's core advice: rebalance inside your tax-sheltered accounts first, your 401(k), IRA, or Roth, so you're not accidentally generating capital gains on assets you've held for years. If you must rebalance in a taxable account, look for losses you can harvest to offset any gains. With the Nasdaq down 2.25% in a single session and names like Nvidia off nearly 49% from their highs, there's no shortage of harvesting opportunities right now.
The bear case for sitting still is that volatility at this level tends to have aftershocks. The bull case is that selloffs with real macro catalysts (geopolitics, rate fears) often overshoot to the downside, and rebalancing into weakness is literally the definition of buying low. You're not predicting the bottom. You're just doing math.
Either way, the worst rebalancing strategy is the one you do in a panic at 2 AM while reading Iran war headlines. Set your targets, check your tax situation, and let the spreadsheet make the call, not the VIX.